Second Annual Student Senate Town Hall Meeting: Q&A with Dr. Brian Knetl and Executive Leadership Team

By: Johnny Crouch, Sports & Activities Executive
Photos By:

On Monday, Oct. 13, the Student Senate hosted a Town Hall Meeting at Waubonsee Community College’s Sugar Grove Campus in the APC Event Room from 2 – 4 p.m. The event was led by Student Senate President Michelle Alaniz and gave students the chance to ask questions directly to President Dr. Brian Knetl and members of the college’s executive team.

Light refreshments were provided, and a suggestion board was available for students to share feedback and ideas for future improvements on campus. This year’s event focused entirely on a live Q&A session, allowing students to raise their concerns and questions on the spot.

Alaniz opened the event by welcoming attendees and introducing the college leadership panel, which included Chief of Staff and Vice President of Strategy Dr. Toya Webb, Faculty Union President and Professor of Health and Information Technology Patty Saccone, Vice President of Talent and Culture and Chief Diversity Officer Dr. Anthony Ramos, Vice President of Finance and Administration John Bryant, Chief of Campus Police JC Paez, Provost Dr. Kimberly Chavis and Assistant Provost of Academic and Student Success Dr. Scott Peska.

Alaniz began by welcoming attendees and outlining a few ground rules to keep the discussion respectful and focused. She emphasized that this was a space for constructive dialogue and reminded students to stay on topic, keep their questions professional and allow panelists time to respond. The first portion of the event featured questions submitted in advance by students who RSVP’d, which helped guide the discussion before the floor was opened for live questions. Students brought up a wide range of topics throughout the two-hour session, including ICE activity and campus safety, food accessibility, childcare, transportation, athletics, student organizations and free speech.

Q: Has Waubonsee faculty met to discuss what would happen if ICE came to campus? What is being done to protect staff and students?

Read More

Saccone: Faculty have received training, so we did go through training. As for working with police here at Waubonsee, we know the process that’s involved, and we are also in continued discussions about moving forward as the system as it unfolds. We have yet to see ICE on campus, not that I wish you for anything like that, but we are working with helping students that are impacted by this in that maybe they fear attending classes or submitting assignments or coming in person.

Kentl: One of the things I’ll offer is that I want to acknowledge that we are doing everything we can. Actually I’m not saying we’re doing everything we can anymore. We’re doing what we can at the time because we learn different strategies. We’re working with community partners. We’re listening to a lot of the student voices, and we’re trying to adjust our protocols as best we can, to do as much as we can to keep our students safe on campus. In addition to some of the things that professor Saccone talked about, we are in regular meetings with our community partners and really trying to provide students with resources. So you have seen some of our emails, you know, we’re trying to connect you to some of those resources. We’re trying to mobilize that support for students, we know last week there was some really close and significant activity in Aurora, and we’re also trying to change some of our processes. We have a pretty well documented process working through our chief of police that triggers a variety of other things to happen with ICE on campus, but we also know that there is a great deal of anxiety and stress created when there’s ICE activity within the community, and so we’re trying to figure out now what some of that looks like. And there was some great grassroots efforts on Thursday at the downtown Aurora campus, when things were happening just a few blocks and a couple of miles away from campus. And we’re looking to have conversations on if that is something we can formalize and mobilize, I would probably say if rather than when, but if and when some of this happens again, so that we can make sure we’re providing as much support as possible. Also, we’ve been talking with partner colleges and partner businesses. We’re coming up with a few other strategies. We do have a plan that I’m going to look at tonight for designating certain spaces as private spaces, designated classroom spaces during class time limited to registered students and faculty. We need to review that and make sure that we can take the steps we want to to designate that. So as I said, we’re doing everything we know how at the time, may not be everything we can, but if there’s more that we learned that we can do, we will have those discussions to make sure that we are that we are doing that as well.

Ramos: And I’ll just add in, we also have a group of staff that are engaged and we’re forming a group of individuals who could be notified in a moment’s notice to be able to support across all four campuses. And so some of that training, we are leaning on external partners, whether it’s Rapid Response Training, know your rights training, and just to make sure we have as much information that we can have on hand, as well as to know what are the practices and protocols that happen when we activate and reach out to these external sources. We know these are uneasy times. We know these are not normal times. And so trying to be as prepared as we can be to deploy supports and resources as soon as we know that they are needed. So there’s a lot of training and conversations that are happening around us. And so as for example, a service is putting on a rapid response training tomorrow afternoon, and we’re encouraging folks to consider that training so knowing your rights, but that what does that response look like? And even if somebody might not be on the front lines of response, to be able to know what is happening in the community so we could support what’s happening on our campus.

Q: What policies does Waubonsee have in place to protect students and faculty from ICE?

Read More

Paez: Well, first of all, protecting the campus community itself is the number one responsibility. So I want to ensure you, that’s what we’re here for. The colleges have a number of protocols in place. I do encourage you if you haven’t done so, make sure you check your emails, because I get a lot of the questions repeated, and I know we’ve sent out emails. There have been numerous emails, adding information that we gain, like Dr Knetl mentioned, but what we are assuring as far as campus police, if ICE were to ever come on campus, I had reached out to ICE, and I asked them to notify us in advance. I don’t know they ever would. I’m still being told that they are not planning to come on college campuses to enforce but if they did on one of the practices we have set in places for any of our faculty and staff to immediately contact campus police so that we can communicate with ICE. We can check the paperwork, see if they have an arrest warrant, see they have a civil warrant, and then deal with it accordingly, depending on the requirements of the law, and that’s probably the most important practice that we have, so that we can step in between, not necessarily intervene or stop it, but actually be there to make sure that they’re following the law.

Kentl: We are constantly updating our processes, again, especially as we hear back from from students, and we send out communications, and we have forums like this. We do get feedback, and we try to update it. I know we’re in the process of updating some of the clarity. We know that our best first step on campus is to work through the campus police. But we also want to clarify for you all the things that happen beyond it, what our counselors and advisors will be doing and how they will be available for students. John Bryant will be in contact with our legal department to see if there’s anything that we can do for that, and I will be in contact with some of our local elected officials. We’ll be doing everything we can also behind the scenes, and sometimes you don’t see some of that, but it does not just stop with contacting the police. There’s a lot of other things behind the scenes to support students, and we feel we need to be maybe a little bit clearer on documenting that process for you, and that’s what we’re going to do.

Bryant: I would just add one other thing, that when it comes to access to student information, FERPA is still applicable. So we’re going to make sure that whatever it is if there’s any requests that come in for information from any federal agency or external sources, that we’re following those guidelines and those restrictions so that we are protecting student information to the utmost of our ability.

Saccone: I also wanted to add just a little bit about faculty’s role in the communication with students. Faculty awarding and affording some grace to students with their attendance records, as well as flexibility with assignments to those that are directly impacted. Again, that’s something that is being communicated to faculty. We do have faculty development days coming up this week as well, where we’re going to make sure the message is out. It’s very similar to what we did during covid as well. It’s responding to students needs.

Ramos: We do have some great resources in our surrounding community as well, and we lean on a lot of those resources for help. And they have whole staffs and people who are connected to other resources in the community, so we lean on them. So part of what we want to try to do is make sure that you are aware of all of those resources that you also have access to.

Q: Have faculty met to discuss protocols if ICE comes to either campus?

Read More

Saccone: We were given training through HR, so we do understand the process in place as Chief Paez explained, as well as Dr Knetl, so we do, and as I said, it’s something that we’re continuing to meet and discuss as it unfolds, to see what services we can provide and support students.

Q:  Why can’t student organizations use the cafeteria during peak hours?

Read More

Peska: We have seen a growth in students coming back in high demand and using that space during the peak periods. So again, we’re keeping that space open and accessible for everyone. So we look at it really from that perspective, and when we look at preserving space that may allow people to change the setup of it, it might look at bringing in outside speakers, could have audio or visuals, which really changes the dynamics of that space. And so right now, when you have people coming over, they’re coming in between classes, they’re coming to get lunch, sometimes sitting socially. So it’s really created and designated as more of an informal space. The other part is, I think if we were to allow access at that peak time to a couple privileged student organizations, I think what that would do is, for those individuals or smaller groups that might not even be aware that it’s a reservable space, could make them believe that space is always usable. So I think really trying to keep it open and accessible for all, and being used as its intended. We do have space real close in the student center where we can do programming so we do try to help student groups so they can use this space. We can obviously advertise and recruit, if you want to attract people to come over from the student center. So that’s really the intended purpose of why we have other spaces for programs.

Knetl: So it’s not that it’s not reservable, just certain periods of time. So I think it really is about balancing that desire to allow students to go over there during that peak time, get a piece of pizza, get a sandwich and have a lunch, do some homework study, instead of having a large organization having an event there, and it’s trying to find that right balance. And we do have, as Dr Peska said, some other spaces. So it’s not that it’s not available. We just want to make sure that people have a quiet place to go and eat and not be overtaken by by a particular event. I think that’s part of the balance that we’re trying to find.

Q: What is Waubonsee doing in regards to upgrading some of the older/outdated buildings on campus?

Read More

Knetl: I will share just a few weeks ago, we actually took our board on a tour of some of our facilities that we think are in the most need of renovation. We know there’s a lot of spaces on campus that have not been touched in a long time, student spaces, office spaces, actually behind the scenes spaces. So some of the spaces that really need a lot of attention are spaces that you might not even see a lot of the time. But the library-Collins Hall, Todd library-are some of those really big spots that we need to address. So we are doing that assessment. I have committed to the board of within this year having a full plan, a long term plan of what spaces we need to do, how much it’s going to cost, how we’re going to fund it. You know, a college space renovation plan takes several years to implement. So unfortunately, from your last semester here, you might not see a lot of of those changes you’re getting to enjoy; the TEC, the pickleball and tennis courts and some other renovations that we’ve taken on, but we are kind of engaged in a formal facilities planning project and timeline to make sure that stuff is done.

Bryant: I must also add that we’re also looking at program needs as well as we design and look at what spaces we’re going to be updating, how we’re going to update those so that they’re stable for a long period of time, and they’re meeting the academic needs of our students, not just today, but we anticipate within the next few years, so that we can meet those needs. We want that flexibility. We’ve been talking to our board over the last year about, you know, this capital planning process and where the funding would come from. What are some of the major projects? There are also infrastructure issues that are kind of behind the scenes, making sure that the heating works and the cooling works. Those sorts of things. That’s all part of that capital plan. So we’re working through all those details, working with academic areas to identify what those programmatic needs are likely to be, so that we can address those it’s not just, you know, putting a fresh look. So far as Collins Hall, we’re already in the initial phases of what will it take to do that renovation? We’re looking at selecting an architect, an engineering firm, to assist us with that. So there are steps being taken. There is a process like Patrick had mentioned. These are multi year plans, multi year projects to execute. So it will take time to execute, but it’s on our radar as a high priority for us to get that plan a little bit more detail and moving forward.

Knetl: And we know there have been a lot of suggestions, we’ve heard your voice before. There has been a lot of requests for some additional student spaces, especially in Sugar Grove. We are aware of that, you know, we’re trying to put that in as part of the plan. That is not something that we think needs a major renovation, but might need some attention. So we are looking at identifying , and it is kind of related to the cafeteria question, other spaces where students might be able to have some of those events that they’re looking to hold, that they would have typically held in the cafeteria during those peak times.

Bryant: One of the things that I will mention as we look at those programmatic needs and we look at that design phase, we’ll be looking to get student input as well as we do that, so we’ll want the student voice to be reflective of what we’re going to do going forward.

Q: What steps are the college taking to ensure affordable food options in the student cafe? Healthier options as well?

Read More

Bryant: So we’ve been working with Paisano’s now for I think our fourth year. We work with them every year to review prices, menus, options there. This is the first year that we’ve raised prices so reflective of inflation that’s happened the last several years, especially with food products. We recognize there has been some need to raise prices, but there’s also efforts that the college is making to support those operations, so those purchasers of the food services aren’t bearing 100% of the cost. We also have a micro market now at Fox Valley to support needs there. We have several places across campus where there’s free food available through donations with a variety of different canned goods, non perishable goods, and we’re also looking at a food survey within the next couple of weeks, probably going out to students to gather some interest, as well as looking at what other fresh food options are so trying to balance affordability and sustainability, recognizing that our partners have to generate a certain amount of revenue to be viable within these spaces, but also then make it also accessible to students. But there’s other community resources as well that we’re able to encourage students who might not be able to afford on campus food options, whether it be through food bank or community college.

Knetl: And we know that coming to campus and needing quick, healthy, affordable access to food is really important. And we knew that coming in, you know. When I started here, we had just had Paisano’s. We didn’t have any of these other sources, so we knew we had to provide some additional solutions. And Dr. Peska can speak a little bit more to that, but a lot of what we’re doing is in response to some of the the feedback that we’ve gotten from you. It’s not just in one spot. Let’s spread it out. So we’re trying to spread solutions out across the college, and we’re now hearing about certain healthier food options.

Q: When will the daycare be running again?

Read More

Knetl: I don’t know. Yeah. I don’t know. We do know that child care is an obstacle for some of our students. It’s a challenge for some of our students. We are taking some baby steps, really, no pun intended, but we are taking some steps towards making something happen. As you know, some of you may know, we have a partnership with the Boys and Girls Club, so they are offering free childcare during limited hours at our downtown Aurora campus. I know that is not a solution, but we’re trying to find solutions where we can, when we come up with a solution, this is the challenge, right? Because, you know, you can all sit here and say, ‘Dr Knetl, you’ve been talking about this two years, three years, you keep bringing it up. We keep asking you do you have a solution?’ Trust me, if we had an affordable, easy solution that would meet your needs, we would have put it in place already. And it’s that balance that we’re trying to find, finding something that will work and allow the college to sustain it over time. One of the reasons the child care centers left was because it was very expensive. Not only for the college, but for people to use it, and one of the other reasons that went away is it wasn’t serving the people who we felt could benefit from it the most, which is some of our students, a lot of staff use it, and we know our staff have some of those challenges, but we want to make sure we come up with a solution to child care. It is going to be sustainable, and we’re not constantly trying to make it work and find funding resources for it. We want to make sure that it’s serving you as our students, and that means it needs to be affordable, open at certain times when you would need it, and doesn’t commit you to four hours a day or eight hours a day, but could really be dropped in babysitting. Our best solution to that is going to be what we’re trying to do with Boys and Girls Club through partnerships. Dr Tejada, who does community engagement for us, has been reaching out to YMCAs and United Way, who also have initiatives trying to go with childcare. So we’re going to keep working at it. We’re going to keep our ears open, our eyes open. I know this is a challenge for a lot of our students, and maybe students who don’t even get in our doors because we don’t have this. And that is a real thing that does on stay our mind as well. So if there are ideas, if you’ve got connections, we are open to hearing more and more solutions. But no, we are working at it all the time.

Webb: I appreciate the question, and I wanted to add that this is certainly top of mind for us, as a matter of fact, within RISE; strengthen the student experience, we have a group that is working on removing barriers for students. So that’s child care, transportation and food insecurity also coming up. We will launch the student advisory group. I’m looking forward to having our first meeting as part of the students who are working on that group. We’ll be working with the strengthening group so that we can address some of these barriers that we continue to hear about. But I just wanted to mention that it is top of mind for us, and we will address this as part of RISE.

Q: Why have the food prices gone up in the cafe?

Read More

Bryant: We touched on this a little bit earlier when we talked about this, so responsiveness of increased input costs reflected the sustainability needs, and trying to find that balance between being a good partner with our vendors, as well as picking an affordable option for students.

Peska: And I’ll just add, we do meet with our vendors, Paisano’s and Endiro. We talk to them pretty frequently about where their pricing is at what state they’re letting us know what’s selling, what’s not selling, and trying to look at being responsive. I know Paisano’s really is very aware of what the average price is, what someone purchases per meal, and so they are kind of trying to keep the prices low. And we do have two senators. I just want to give a shout out if you could stand up, senators are on the food committee, so we have to two senators that are there. So please, if you have any suggestions or specifics, see them, they’ll bring it back to us. But we do. We are creating a survey. It went out to employees the last few weeks, so employees have access to a survey that’s out there. It was on our weekly messages. And so I think there’s gonna be an email being sent out about that to employees, but we’re just creating one to get a few more specifics for students questions, so that should hopefully come out probably next week sometime.

Q: Are you working on expanding options and varieties for Criminal Justice courses? 

Read More

Saccone: So right now, we do have a criminal justice program. We also have paralegals, so we do have options there as for expansion in the curriculum. I believe we’ve been looking in to expanding with criminal justice as well, looking for a degree, Associates Degree, focusing in on that.

Chavis: I can just say we also are looking at some healthcare programming. We know that there are a lot of programs that are Fox Valley campus, and that particular campus is full now, and so we’re thinking about programming here on this campus that students have asked for for a number of years. And so there are going to be additional curricular options as time goes on.

Knetl: And I’ll add just because you might not know, right, there’s a whole process we go through to develop a program, and yes, we listen to students, and we want to know what students want to study and what they’re interested in. We also want to make sure that if you’re studying something, and you leave here and you go off to work, that there’s jobs in our community, or that there’s transfer pathways for that. So we have a whole process where we get information, we get labor market data, we look at our transfer institutions in our four year school. So if you’re going into the workforce or you’re going to transfer, we want to make sure that those are are set up for you. And those are some of the big things, not the only thing, but some of the big things that we consider. And these are health, career, criminal justice, law, those are things that we are hearing more and more about. As Dr Chavis said, those are some of the things that we are looking into, starting or or expanding.

Alaniz then opened the Q&A session to live student questions. Numerous students asked questions for the executive leadership team to answer.


Q:  How can we add more real world applications to the classroom?

Read More

Saccone: So when we look at real world, I believe we’re looking more at like internships, externships, hands on. We do have programs that are focused, especially in the career side, that we are on sites. We’re doing internships. We’re working with the community. We also have programs that are starting off doing competency based right? So you’re actually doing the skills that require in that job or in that field. Another area that I think that we always look at for curriculum is making it, you know, real and relevant and up to date. And so that’s something that we constantly look at. We do program review of the programs in the areas of study, making sure that we are in connection with the community. Faculty do meet with an advisory committee so we do have connections, making sure that our curriculum isn’t something from the past, that it shows what’s moving forward, making sure our students do have jobs once they do receive a certificate or a degree.

Knetl: So we have a Faculty Development Center, and so the faculty are constantly engaging in professional development. So some of the things that Professor Saccone is talking about, and Dr Chavis is leading, is, what are some of those new practices, best practices that can be scaled up in some of the classrooms and work based learning authentic assignments? Those are something that are increasing more and more. And so one of the many things our teaching and learning center does is it works with faculty to provide them with tools and resources, to develop those skills, to bring to the classroom, to enhance some of that for your learning.

Q: Why can’t there be more transportation for school?  Why can’t there be a nurse on campus?

Read More

Knetl: So let me take those two separate ones. Why can’t there be more transportation? That’s a really good question, and that is a question I ask our community, our elected officials, all the time. Transportation is a top issue for many students at many colleges and universities across the country and having four campuses makes it particularly challenging. And so I think we’re attacking this problem in a variety of ways. So why don’t we? I think there’s lots of limits, right? We serve five counties. A lot of the transportation available to students typically exists within a specific county. We have bus lines, but the bus lines don’t always come to all our campuses and not to Sugar Grove. So there’s a lot of complications in our transportation system that we have little control over, but are trying to take some control of the causes of some of those problems. Scheduling is one way we can attack it by making sure that students don’t have to or minimize their travel between the different campuses. Dr. Webb and I have talked to, as recently as just a couple of weeks ago, a lot of our elected officials. The state is facing a budget cut to their transportation budget in a significant way. So we have been in front of our elected officials telling the story of how challenging transportation is for some of our students and encouraging them to think about cross-county agreements, partnerships between colleges and universities and transportation companies, reduced rates for rideshare so that we can handle some of these things and help our students reduce transportation as a barrier. One of the things we are trying, and I think we’re close, don’t know if it’s going happen this semester, but maybe next semester, is we are trying today’s shuttle to at least start this, again like the boys and girls club tell us the baby step, this is another small step, to run between the downtown Aurora campus and the Sugar Grove campus. So if you can get to one of those campuses, we can help you get back and forth. We’re going to monitor that. We’re going to have all kinds of surveys. We’re going to see what the usage is. And if that’s working and providing a better point of access for our students, then we’ll find ways to expand it. If we decide that’s going to be what’s in the best interest, then we can look to make sure that we address this transportation issue. We know that it’s an issue. The shuttle is going to be one way we’re trying to address that. But just again, so you know, these aren’t always the things that you see. We’ve been in front of our elected officials, we’re working with the cities around us. Why don’t we have a nurse, that’s the first time that question’s been posed. I think we can certainly look into that. Again, a partnership would be great if we partnered with one of our local healthcare systems and try to start out by providing access to some healthcare option at one or two of our campuses certain hours or days of the week. We can certainly look into that. There’s all sorts of financial commitments and planning we have to do, but think that’s certainly a question that we can look at and see again if there are solutions. If the need is there and there are solutions, we’ll see what we can do to.

Q: What steps are administrators taking to help Hispanic students given the current political climate?

Read More

Ramos: I think it’s really important for us to really think about what does safety and support look like and how much we as an institution can partner with students in better understanding of what those needs are. We have to recognize as a Hispanic Serving Institution whether or not that’s designated at the federal level. We have to account for who we serve. Community colleges serve the most diverse student populations nationally. And we have a commitment and part of it is not making assumptions as to what safety and security and support look like. It’s engaging with students. Try to think of where in our policies or practices or procedures that we can create a stronger sense of support and better understanding of what support looks like. This is a commitment we have as an institution, being an HSI and owning our servingness and our responsibilities around that is embedded in our strategic plan of strength in that. And I know there’s been a lot of good conversations about that, but I there’s a lot more work that is waiting for us to engage in. And so I think it’s important that we are engaging with students, hearing their voices, getting a better understanding of what the needs and support looks like, while also partnering with earlier things that were mentioned around how are we working with the hard place department, how are we working with people, how are we looking at our practices around what spaces are designated. And what activities can take place in which spaces so that students as much as possible can feel supported during their time here on campus. And I think really this is where all your voices are so important that I hope that all of our students have someone or an office, department, folks that you can go to where you can feel connected whether it’s your faculty member, staff member, an advisor to share your concerns and questions. So we can have a collective voice as to what you all want and need and so we can be stronger partners in creating an environment where you could thrive, an environment where you could see yourself in all aspects of what we’re doing as an institution. I think that’s a great opportunity for us. And so thank you for the question. And if there’s ideas and thoughts of how we could do that more intentionally, I welcome that conversation.

Knetl: Just know that everything that we hear from the students, we also hear from our community, we’re listening to it. And sometimes you’re asking for something that we can’t do and you might not see the action. And it’s not because we haven’t talked about it, it’s not that we haven’t explored it, there are just some things that we aren’t able to do as an open public campus. But we are trying as much as we can, everything we know now, everything that we know we can do, we are putting as much of that in practice as we can.

Q: Would it be possible to explore adding or designing gender neutral bathrooms on campuses?

Read More

Knetl: If you don’t know we do have gender neutral bathrooms on the campus, Sugar Grove for sure. And we are adding them. When the tech education center opened, there were gender neutral bathrooms in there. Every project and every building redesign that we do, that is part of the discussion. Honestly, I don’t know if we have any on the other campuses yet. But again, hearing this input, know, the two things we’ll do as we think about the renovation projects and the master plan we’re putting together, that will certainly be a part of that process. And if there are buildings that don’t have that and aren’t part of those major renovations, that is something that we can look at putting into part of that. Part of our standard process going forward with renovations does include gender neutral bathrooms but per legal building code it does require gender specific bathrooms as well so we’re trying to maintain that balance. If you didn’t know we had these bathrooms, maybe it’s a note that as these things become available, as we open them, we can certainly make them better known.

Q: What steps will Waubonsee take to protect free speech on campus both in and out of the classroom?

Read More

Ramos: That’s actually something that we’ve been doing quite a bit of work on recently. We have a policy, actually an institutional policy in draft form that will be considered by our board of trustees regarding freedom of expression and speech on campus while also identifying for our procedures and practices what spaces and places may be designated or available for expression and speech while also acknowledging what limitations for example obscene, profane language is not protected by the First Amendment. So I think a lot of this is an opportunity for training and education, but also thinking about where do we, as a public institution, recognize and support freedom of speech and freedom of expression in ways that are available to all members of the community. And so I think those are things that, from a practice perspective and from an opportunities perspective, we’ll look at how are we educating on these practices to set up our procedures, our policies as an institution to support freedom of speech while also thinking about how do we support the engagement of that across campus. There are things that are being shared within the classroom, within events on campus, public engagement on our campus. So there may be a groups that reserves space on campus to have an event. And how does our female expression practices aligned with supporting the First Amendment while also creating spaces where that could be respected and executed in safe and supportive ways. We also recognize that part of the planning process might be if there is going to be some sort of engagement on campus that do we have the proper support and protections in place. So if there’s large group coming on campus to have an event to express their freedom of speech, that we have systems of processing in place to ensure safety of our constituents.

Q: How does the federal funding for HSI’s being cut impact Waubonsee?

Read More

Knetl: I mean, could talk for a long time about this. It is very unfortunate that our HSI funding was cut. And as many of you know, just the federal designation of an HSI is being questioned and may or may not go away. The federal designation of it. And it’s terrible. I haven’t talked to any college, community college, university president who thinks it’s a good thing. I think about a few things, and I shared this with groups before. Whether or not we have a federal designation, we are here to serve our students and the reality is over 40 % of our students identify as some Hispanic lineage and we will continue to lead into that servingness for those students. I think about the fortune, the good fortune we have as an institution, we have the community, finances, the board support to continue to providing the programs, the resources that those grant funded dollars supported. For decades of really good fiscal management, we’ve been able to have enough funds that when things like our Title V grant go away, when things like TRIO go away, we have the talent, we have the resources to see how we can continue that work so that those students aren’t put at any disadvantage by those federal decisions really that are beyond our control taking place. So again, I could talk about it for a long time. I’ll let Dr. Ramos give an opportunity to respond. But again, what I would want to reiterate is that even though those funds have been cut, Waubonsee has committed to and is finding ways to continue that work and continue leading to that circuit.

Ramos: And with regards to the funds, we were in a fortunate position that the Title V grants that were tied to our HSI identity, we were actually on the tail end of that, and all funds that we received were spent. And so from an operational perspective, other colleges might have been in the middle of their five-year period. We were able to at least see the end of the grant dollars that we were committed to by the federal government. And to what Dr. Knetl said, we are finding ways to continue the support. As an example, we have institutionalized our Latinx Resource Center that was started in the last grant and commit that through institutional dollars and support. And we know that culturally relevant services and programming is so important in helping our populations of students here to thrive. For all students at the college to recognize that this is a value and this is a significant contribution and a place of belonging that is created while also sharing with the wider community the assets, the strengths of this community and how we can partner with community to continue creating an environment that is supportive here at the college. And so the fact that we still have more work to continue doing and we are committed to that work. So whatever the federal government is going to do or not do, we are committed and we are putting our support behind.

Q: I feel it is vital for staff members to have a boundary regarding political views and morals influencing their work/duties. How can higher administration keep that fine line that way students feel safe, especially for law enforcement?

Read More

Knetl: I think it’s really important that faculty, staff, administration as they’re coming to their work keep in mind that their primary focus, their primary job is to support you. Everybody, all of our students, everybody up here, we come to our work with political beliefs. We have religious beliefs. We have experiences that shape who we are. That’s just part of us all being human. But a lot of our job, whether it’s in the classroom, whether it’s as the college president or a staff member or advisor is to help you as you come to us with your ideas, with your beliefs, with your perspectives and lived experiences, to help support you the best way we know how and to support the person that you are. Sometimes they challenge some of those ideas and some of those beliefs, but our job is never to try to impart our personal beliefs onto you. Again, if we’re asking questions and we’re having a debate, whether that’s a group of faculty, a group of administrators, or a student and staff, or student and faculty member, we need to try to make sure we’re always finding that line. That is really one of the hallmarks of higher education. How do we ensure that? I think from time to time, we may have to remind each other of some things, remind each other of that, especially during tense times when those human emotions start to come out, you may need to check each other. We do provide valuable training through human resources, you know. Faculty are having these conversations all the time when they talk about academic freedom, what does that truly mean? We may be imperfect in some of that, but I think we’re very well aware of that responsibility. And when we see violations of that, when we tend to step over that sometimes, we just need to make sure we’re holding each other gently and civilly accountable to that and likewise from students to us.

Q: Have there been any discussions about providing an on-campus nurse or wellness space for students?

Read More

Peska: As Dr. Webb alluded to a little bit earlier, this is one of the areas that we are looking at through the whole RISE initiative. And so we are starting to recognize that we are offering a lot of small services everywhere. So I can only speak in depth about our mental health area. We try to approach mental health as more of a holistic approach, and we know it’s more than just your mental health, but it also affects your physical well-being and everything. As we haven’t had a nurse traditionally, that is something that based on feedback today we would love to explore. But going back through the RISE initiative, what we’re going to try to do is find out what different areas already are offering, because we know that there are some things happening in different areas. As far as, for example, for us, we connect students through the Kane County Health Department. We look at those and some students may need to be referred to a doctor for more physical needs versus know mental health. And so we use IRIS through Kane County Health Department to connect students that way. But again I know that’s not something that’s on our campus, but it is something that we’re exploring to see what the needs are. So right now we’re in the early stages, but we’re hoping to do some outreach, and that’ll include some student connections to find out what exactly are those needs are. I think in our dream world, we do want to see a space dedicated to a whole holistic care for our students. That includes counselors that we already have, but also adding more as far as addressing basic needs like food and housing.

Knetl: And just very quickly, access to mental health spaces and over contracts. We do have the vending machines. We can have a naming contest. I’m not sure exactly what they’re called. But we do have access to some of those resources. And we do have a mental health room on the second floor of Bodie that was funded through mental health action dollars that is available. And again, this might be just one of those where more visibility of these things could be helpful.

Peska: We just put in the wellness kiosks. That’s the informal name for them right now. But there’s one on each campus. And so we do have the one on this campus in the student center right now but we are going to probably move that into a different location. But we are excited, if there’s things that you want to see in that, please come forward let us know. Our venue partner that we have has put a number of things in there that are required by the state. But then also just trying to think of what students want or may want to see in there. 

Q: When are the new tennis and pickleball courts going to be open?

Read More

Knetl: They’re scheduled for a soft opening ribbon cutting on November 8th, so right around early to mid November is when they’re ready. We’ll have a big event, bike the burbs, November 8th, and the hope is that the courts will be ready for some open play. And then just in time for winter, but next spring they’ll be great and ready to go.

Q: This is regarding the student center and the testing area above. There are lots of events in the student center that can often create a lot of noise or distractions for test takers, have you considered possibly moving the testing area to a different location?

Read More

Knetl: Dr. Peska and I had a conversation not too long ago about this and is that the best location for the testing area because we like the Student Center. We want it to be a place where students can gather and have events and play music, but we do know that it creates a noise issues. Right now we don’t have a great place to move that Student Center, but also address that noise issue. So when we think about some of these projects that are going on at Collins, for example, which is the library, the tutoring center. I think it’s not just a ‘let’s remodel what’s there.’ I think it’s complete re-envisioning of that space. And when we think about what that space could become, we’re also thinking about it with the student center. We’re thinking about it with that land between those. And how can we create a student corridor between the student center, the outdoor space, and Collins? And as we think about what goes where and we shuffle things around, that’s going to be of significant consideration. Where can we have student events where the noise might not impact places where students need quiet study, where there’s classes going on. So there’s not an easy solution right now because then if we tell student life you’ve got to turn the music down or you can’t have music or their microphones, then their event suffers a little bit. The testing center is okay, but if you have a good event with lots of music and microphones, the event is great, but then the testing center is impacted . Right now we’re somewhat space-limited. So when we talk about how to solve some of those problems in conjunction with our new master planning process, all of that’s in consideration.

Q: Some of us were wondering why the pickleball and tennis courts were made before any other advancements toward athletics, like better batting cages or better fields?

Read More

Peska: So the initial thought was we had some damage to the current tennis courts in the facility when the tornado came through. So that provided an opportunity for us to be able to quickly look at that space and make some changes. The athletic director and her leadership team present everywhere what the issues are and what some of the top priorities they have to address, and there’s a number of things with baseball fields, softball fields and getting things leveled. All of those do take priority, so she tries prioritize out which ones we should look at each year and what we should take action on. We do try to budget and work very closely with the athletics team and they’ve partnered very closely with our facilities team to figure out this is something that we are able to accomplish this next year.

Knetl: And when we think about priorities, when we’re looking at it, and I know the condition, as Dr. Peska mentioned, of some of those fields. So those need to be upgraded, certainly, but we didn’t have tennis courts at all. So when we think about, you know, do we create something or upgrade something? We had a tennis team. Tennis is a Skyway sport, that’s the conference that our athletics belong to. So we’d love to be able to do all of it. Mr. Bryant knows I’d love to be able to do all of the facilities all at once and have it all done. But we do need to prioritize and we knew that in addition to some of the practical features that happen, we wanted to provide a space that we didn’t have before for a team. So then, now once those are done, we start shifting and looking at other spaces.

Q: If a student wanted to start a club similar to Turning Point, how would the college approach that? Given the current climate in our community, do you believe it would be appropriate to approve this club and are you guys prepared for any backlash?

Read More

Peska: I would say that any club that wants to come on campus, any national charter club, if they want to come on campus, we have a really distinct kind of what we have to follow as far as what the student senate and what we have laid out for starting any club and organization. And we have put practices in there saying these clubs have to be open to all students at the campus. We try to make sure that any club that comes in will be respectful and open to any other members that want to join. I know that your question was specifically with turning point. That could be somewhat of a politically divisive club. I think we’re in a time right now that is really unfortunate where one of the challenges that you all face is that that’s a number one priority as far as distinction. When I was going to college, political differences wasn’t the number one thing. It was race relations. That was the number one. Today, I read in the Atlantic that one of the new issues that college students are asking for when deciding roommates is what is someone’s political background and how strongly of a difference it is? I think for us what we want to embrace, and this is a college setting, we want to be a place where we can have discourse and we can learn and grow from each other. And so we have to do that to make sure that we have stability and respect. And we would make sure that those same ideals are tied to every one of our clubs and organizations in the type of events that they might hold or etc. At this point we do not have a turning point chapter on this campus, but if someone’s exploring it we would go through the same steps that we would for any club or organization.

Ramos: Just a minor clarification, so there’s Turning Point and Turning Point USA, so locally there’s a group that supports adults with autism called Turning Point as well in terms of naming convention. So the question about Turning Point USA and their preparedness level, which I think is a great question. I think it is really giving us an opportunity to have conversations about what does it look like to have civil discourse on our campus. We would need to set expectations to think about our code of conduct among employees, students, and to really create a place where stability can happen on campus and a sort of open conversation while creating an environment that is structured around learning and support. And so we have some opportunities as you talk about being prepared. I think we do have level of preparedness, but I think we can engage in more conversations about what does support look like? What do expectations look like for student organizations? What do expectations look like for student leaders who are stepping up into different roles for different organizations and how we as staff administrators, faculty, all student organizations have a dedicated advisor from the institution. How are those advisors supported to support student organizations as well? So I think we have some opportunities for strengthening conversations around this. While also we want to be a place where civil discourse can occur while supportive student needs is prioritized.

Knetl: I would just add that, you know, yes, we are ready for the feedback. If something were to start, we would still have the same expectations of behavior, civil discourse, living our mission, vision and values. There isn’t any club that we would allow to act, say or do things in a hateful way. Higher Ed is a place where different ideas can exist and be discussed and doesn’t mean that the college or the people participating or the people witnessing or attending that school agree with everything. And when Dr. Peska said, ‘how do we learn from each other,’ we might not think that other club has anything to offer us. And I’m not saying you have to take something from that other club, but we do become better whether we’re challenging our ideas, honing our own ideas, strengthening the arguments for our own ideas. Higher Ed is that place where it has to happen. If we start deciding which clubs can come on and can’t come on based on what we agree with or don’t agree with, I think that’s where not just the college, but higher ed starts to get in trouble. And we have to demonstrate that we can elevate our conversations on this campus beyond what happens outside of our own walls. And then when we go back out into the world we are helping elevate those conversations.

Q: I was wondering if the school can give transportation for nursing students to go to the clinical sites. Many students travel 40 to 50 minutes just to get there. I was also wondering if you guys can expand the student rooms in Fox Valley since it’s very limited.

Read More

Knetl: Others can try to chime in, but thank you for bringing that. I haven’t heard either of those challenges before. I mean, other than transportation, but specifically related to the distance to clinical’s. I’d love to be able to say yes, but I can’t. We can look into some possible solutions or some things that we can do. In the student space, we want to make sure students have space to study and to relax, to take breaks. Fox Valley is probably our most densely used campus of all four of them. So we will try to get really creative as we look at what some of those spaces might look like. I’m all for creative solutions and you’re probably down there much more than I am so I’d encourage people who are at Fox Valley, if they have ideas, share them with us.

Chavis: Yes, I would just say, this is the first time I’ve heard a request for transformation to clinical sites. And all of the students, almost all of the students at Fox Valley will have to go to a clinical site throughout their curriculum. And so I think that’s something we can certainly look into. We can also look into how far out are we have our clinical sites. Is there a way for us to get sites that are maybe closer to the campus so people don’t have to travel this far?

Q: If someone were to be hostile at a club like Turning Point for example, how would you make sure that the environment stays healthy and friendly?

Read More

Knetl: Yeah, definitely easier said than done, right? And I think, you know, we would have to, with any club. It’s not just this one. I don’t want it to feel like we’re signaling out one particular club. With any club, there’s expectations, right? And if there is a desire to have that back and forth, we would have what we would call time, place, and manner restrictions. We would want to make sure that it stays controlled and stays civil. And we would, you know, try to say, hey, these are the expectations on where you can do this, how you can do this, who you can engage. If people are walking by and engaging and choosing to engage, that’s one thing. Rather than yelling at somebody. We would rely on our student leaders, our student life leaders, some of us administrators. If we have an event that we think is going to be challenging, then we ask for that presence. But I think one of the things with any club, what we have to understand is, that if we, assuming civility and values and mission of the institution, which includes free speech, are recognized and adhered to, just because you hear something you don’t like doesn’t mean it’s bad behavior. And that goes all around, on different sides of the political spectrum, the religious spectrum. So again, it’s easier said than done. If some of those events do come to fruition, we will have to plan for those. We’ve already had conversations about that. Because we don’t want to restrict speech, but we also don’t want things to get out of hand, and we don’t want things to violate what we would consider civil discourse of, again, exchange of ideas is one thing. Name calling, profanity, that’s something we would have to address and we would be prepared to address those in the moment.

Peska: And I’ll just add, we have had events on campus years before you were students here that have been divisive in nature and have been challenging and we have addressed clubs and student behavior individually. So, if we have individuals that are making comments or doing things that are inappropriate, we will hold them to the standard of our student code of conduct and they go through that process. If we have clubs that are embracing certain behavior, they go through the same process. And we can suspend a club from being on campus if they’re not following the protocols or not following the behavior that we need to in our student code of conduct. So we do live by those standards and those ideals and we do hold every single club to those same ideals. And we have a group of a lot of student leaders in here. Know the hardest thing you would face as a leader is, you know, acknowledging that all of our clubs, going through the process, have the right to exist and to hold events and to be here. And what can you do to help us support that culture and say, just because you’re listening to something, just because the college is allowing that to happen, within all of our parameters, doesn’t mean you have to agree. It’s important to see all the time at colleges and universities these demonstration spaces that say these views, whatever they are, are not necessarily reflective of the college or the administration or the whole campus community. So it’s a challenge for higher ed to live up to what I think of as one of higher ed’s core values.

Q: Will there be any alternative to TRIO now that it is being defunded?

Read More

Chavis: So we are looking at incorporating the best parts of TRIO throughout all of our student supports. So even though it’s not called TRIO, even though the government is not funding it, we still will be using the things that were a part of TRIO that really help a lot of students. So it won’t be called TRIO, but the services that were provided will be available still.

Q: If an undocumented student were to approach you for resources regarding immigration, how would you help them?

Read More

Paez: I would provide them with any and all resources that we have. I think the college has done a wonderful job providing a lot of those resources, and I would, of course, answer any questions and help in any way possible that I could. The best part of the resources I have is all these people on the executive board. So even if I can’t provided you with an answer, I can direct you to one of the tremendous amount of administrators we have to help you and your situation. We will get through this tough time, just like we did with COVID or any other tough time.

Q: What are your opinions on the current political climate especially with immigration and undocumented students?

Read More

Knetl: What I would offer is going back to one of earlier questions, asking about a personal opinion, you know, I think what’s important for us and our roles is to make sure we are doing what we can to support students. And while we have personal opinions, while we have different beliefs up here, that should not impact the way we do our work. I won’t speak for Chief Paez, but I just want to make sure that we reiterate that our personal opinions on some of these issues are not as important as how we support the students and how we live up to mission, vision, and values of Waubonsee Community College to make sure that you all are feeling as though you are supported and that you are safe.

Q: Would you consider sending a message or maybe even a short video to our students who are directly affected by ICE to show they have your support and you care?

Read More

Knetl: I’ll say a couple of things in response to that. First, I do truly care, and I’m saying that now, and I’ll say that I care about all of our students and our students that face particular challenges at any given point. I certainly care. Would I find a way to reach out to those individual students? Absolutely. I don’t know why we wouldn’t do that. That’s something that we can talk about. If there are individual students that we know of who are facing a particular challenge, I think that’s what we do up here. We support all of our students and our individual students need individual support. We find the best ways that we know how and I’ll acknowledge too that some students may not feel comfortable. If we can create an environment where if there are folks who are seeking that kind of support, I think the group that we are forming on campus is going to be a strong group of allies where we’ll have individuals across every campus who are receiving deeper training to support and help where they are needed, but also if there’s other ways that we can let folks know that we care and that we can support I would love to do that.

Alaniz closed the Town Hall by thanking both the panel and the students for their participation. “Thank you to Dr. Knetl and our college leadership for taking the time to answer our questions and engage with our student body, and a big thank you to all the students who participated today. Your voices matter, and we appreciate your engagement. If you have additional questions or concerns, Student Senate is always here to advocate for you. Feel free to reach out at any time. We look forward to continuing these conversations and working together to enhance Waubonsee Community College,” Alaniz said.

Leave a comment